Blog Short #257: Why You Should Question Your Emotions

Photo by Pablo Merchán Montes for Unsplash+
Ask yourself this question:
What would happen if you were suddenly unable to use your thinking brain and had to rely solely on your emotions to run your life?
It would be a s*** show!
Really, it would be disastrous, and that’s because emotions, although necessary and valuable, are not reliable sources of information. They have significant impact and purpose, but they can’t supplant critical thinking. And, by nature, they often lead us astray.
On the other hand, they are very necessary. Thinking without emotions would also be disastrous. We need a balance of both.
Today, let’s talk about the purpose of emotions, what they do, and what they can’t do. And along with that, how to best use them.
Let’s start with what emotions offer, and what they don’t.
Five Purposes
The first thing to remember when thinking about emotions is that they aren’t good or bad. They just are. What you do with them is what matters.
So don’t suppress them. You need them. Let them come up, and then you can decide how to respond.
Here are five reasons we need our emotions.
1. Our Natural Alarm System
Emotions are the product of our more primitive brain. They are the brain’s mechanism for warning us of danger that could threaten our survival.
Tied to the amygdala in the brain, emotions tell us when to pay attention.
At the same time, the primitive brain can be somewhat catastrophic and blow things out of proportion.
So when you get those niggling feelings of distress coming from your emotional brain, you have to review them mindfully to keep things in proportion to reality.
2. A Source of Drive and Energy
Emotions are like the spark plugs in your car. You can have a super engine, a full tank of gas, and everything in working order, but if you don’t start the car using those spark plugs, you’re not going anywhere.
Emotions supply the energy and drive to take action.
You have an idea, you make a plan, but you won’t be able to carry either of those out if you don’t put some emotional energy behind it.
Your emotions provide the sustained interest, the push to act, and the sense of accomplishment you get when you’re successful.
So they’re not just the spark to start things up, but they keep the engine going and provide the energy to sustain your motivation.
A think tank without emotional drive is just a think tank.
3. Emotions Create Memory
Our brain accumulates memories of events, experiences, and sensory information. However, it’s our emotions that make memories stand out and remain in our memory bank.
The greater the emotional impact something has on you, the more likely it is to find its way into your long-term memory.
This is a researched fact. And also why memories are not always reliable.
We don’t remember verbatim what happens. We remember the impact it has on us. The greater the emotional impact, the stronger the memory.
4. The Great Connecter
Without emotions, we wouldn’t be able to connect to anything.
Even if you’re dealing with complex ideas that come from intense thinking, your connection to them or to someone you’re sharing them with comes from emotional validation and investment.
Without emotion, the ideas would dry up. There would be no feeling of stimulation, interest, or connection.
People who see themselves as mostly rational and view emotions as secondary, or even unnecessary, are fooling themselves. Because without emotions, they wouldn’t be able to invest in or even enjoy their thoughts.
Relationships of any kind require emotions. They are the source of attraction, bonding, appreciation, attachment, and ongoing commitment.
5. Color, Nuance, and Definition
Think of emotions as the paint in a work of art.
The ideas, lines, and shapes are the cognitive aspects of a painting. But the color and shading are the emotional aspects that give it definition and nuance. It’s what allows us to feel the image and connect to it.
A line drawing can do that to an extent, but without shading, we see it more from a cognitive than an emotional perspective. Still beautiful, but not as connective unless the image itself portrays emotions we connect to.
How to Use Emotions
You can use emotions in all the ways we just defined, but it’s never good to take them at face value. They are highly influenced by past experiences and impressions, as well as discomfort or elation, depending on the situation.
In other words, they can exaggerate aspects of a situation while downplaying others.
Emotions aren’t good historians because of how selective they are, which means you miss information and facts that need consideration.
They also create drama in your mind and can lead you to quick reactions you later regret.
Let your emotions arise, but examine them before acting on them.
Question both your thoughts and feelings before making any decisions that will have a lasting or significant impact.
It’s fine to get lost in feelings that won’t have a negative impact, such as listening to your favorite music and temporarily losing yourself in the pleasure it brings you. But if you become angry at someone and feel compelled to tell them off, you’ll want to pull back and think it through before acting.
Maintain the position as the artist, not the painting itself.
In one of his articles, Nick Wignall writes that there are four reasons to ignore your emotions.
I wouldn’t necessarily ignore them, but I would step back from them in any of these situations and apply some critical thinking to see how exaggerated or accurate they are, and how they might affect your behavior.
I’ve added a fifth one. They are:
- When they conflict with your values
- When they lead to aggression
- When they lead to worry
- When they lead to rumination
- When they lead to destruction
These are all self-evident except for the last one, which requires some definition.
Emotions can easily compel you to ignore consequences. When you feel strongly, you can react quickly without giving it a second thought. This phenomenon is what’s known as emotional hijacking (Goleman).
It happens when your emotional brain is triggered and interprets a stimulus as dangerous, triggering a spontaneous knee-jerk reaction without input from your thinking brain.
The stimulus can come from outside you, such as another person or situation, or from within, through your own thoughts or ruminations.
An example of the former would be shouting horrible, attacking things at your partner in the midst of a rage, and not being able to take them back. In the latter case, someone could self-harm in the midst of intense despair.
These situations result in destructive behavior you can’t undo. Emotions in these cases can have devastating results.
Treat Emotions as Your Creative Partner
Use your emotions in the ways we’ve talked about:
To connect, add color and interest to our life, supply drive and energy, serve as a warning device, and create memories.
But temper it with critical thinking. Be mindful.
That last one isn’t so easy, but it is something you should practice daily.
You need to separate your sense of self from both your thoughts and feelings. Thoughts and feelings are things that arise within you and that you engage with.
The key is that you have a choice in how you engage and to what extent.
Our current culture is heavily biased toward emotions. I was raised in the 50s when culture was heavily biased toward rational thinking, to the exclusion of emotions. We were taught to suppress them and see them as second-class citizens in our minds.
That wasn’t beneficial, but neither is the current focus on emotions and the belief that you should follow your feelings.
No, you shouldn’t. You should use them carefully to inform, but not blindly follow them.
We need a balance and partnership between our emotions and thinking. That way, we get the best of both of them.
Make sure that you’re driving your car, not your feelings.
That’s all for today.
Have a great two weeks and a Happy Thanksgiving!
All my best,
Barbara









