Blog Short #261: How to Stick With New Habits (It’s Not About Willpower)

Photo by Curated Lifestyle for Unplash+
It’s easy to start a new habit. But not so easy to stick with it. That takes work, time, and consistency. Most people would say it takes willpower.
But what exactly is so hard about it? What gets in the way?
In a word? Resistance.
Resistance is always present. It pops up any time you pursue something creative, valuable, or something that requires consistent attention.
It’s that voice that says, “Let me put this off today. I’m not up to it. I deserve a break. I can do it tomorrow.”
That voice is always looking for an opening, and if you give it just a small one, it shoves its way through the door and takes up residence.
I love this quote from Steven Pressfield about resistance. He says:
Resistance never gets easier. It’s diabolical. It’s like the alien that keeps evolving. It gets more subtle and stronger.
He’s right! It throws our dreams overboard, trashes our good intentions, and never sleeps. It’s always waiting in the wings.
So, how do you deal with that?
You can meet it head-on and push through. That works if you’re in the right mindset and have a heavy dose of willpower, but that’s something you can’t rely on. Willpower comes and goes. It’s not reliable.
A better solution is working under the radar. You have to outsmart resistance. Let’s take a look.
Getting Under the Radar
To outsmart resistance, you have to focus on two things:
- Keeping the right mindset
- Showing up when you fail
Let’s go through them.
The Right Mindset
To get in the right mindset, remember these three facts.
1. The antidote to resistance is taking action.
Action, in this case, is any small step forward. Not necessarily big, sweeping actions, but small, tiny actions. Actions create energy, which in turn produces desire and ultimately strengthens willpower. Willpower is a result of action, not the other way around.
2. Secondly, what you do repetitively will become a habit.
Habits require much less energy to maintain once they’re set. Repetition of small actions is more important than occasional leaps.
3. Third, the longer a habit is maintained, the easier it is to keep it going.
You feel the rewards and have a sense of satisfaction that keeps you interested and involved.
Keeping these three facts in mind, what do you do when you start falling off? That’s the big question.
Scale Down
The best advice I’ve heard and used myself to get past this problem comes from James Clear in his book, Atomic Habits.
When you don’t feel like doing that thing you’ve promised yourself you’ll do, he suggests that you “reduce the scope.”
Let’s use exercise as an example, because it’s a habit many people initiate at the beginning of a new year.
Let’s suppose you decide you’re going to walk two miles five days a week outside. You’re excited about it. You even have a treadmill in case the weather is bad, so you can keep going. You schedule it out on your calendar, and you’re ready to go!
The first week is great! You did it, and you’re feeling good and proud of yourself.
Then the second week begins. After four walks that week, you can’t bring yourself to get out there for that fifth one. You don’t feel like it. You’ve got too many things to do. You argue with yourself all day about it and decide it’s just not in the cards today.
Okay, that’s just one day. You’ll do it tomorrow. That’ll work!
Then the next day comes, and you hesitate again. Because you missed a day, you feel like you’ve blown it already, but you still hang on to the idea.
Another day goes by, and another, and by the end of next week, you haven’t walked at all, and that’s it. You’re done. You give it up.
You tell yourself you’ll get back to it next month. But we know what happens, right?
Several factors here contributed to that failure.
1. Your initial intention was too big in scope.
Five days a week is a lot, especially if you already have a busy schedule. The distance is also too much. Two miles requires more energy than you might have, especially at the outset.
Start with something that’s much less time-consuming, takes less effort, and you won’t dread once the original excitement wears off.
You could walk three times a week for just 15 minutes, and no more, until that habit is well established. Or you could scale down even more and walk five minutes. Then, you slowly increase in small increments when you’re ready.
You have to choose actions that sit just below your resistance radar. It has to be easy, enjoyable, and small enough. Scale down enough so it’s doable without too much effort.
The goal is to keep the habit alive until it’s installed.
2. You’re operating from an all-or-nothing approach.
You either do it all, or you do nothing. You walk five days a week or no days. You walk two miles, or none.
You recognize the perfectionistic belief here, right? You do it perfectly or not at all.
Habits don’t operate this way.
When you create a habit, you have to build resilience. That means figuring out how to deal with failures without letting them throw you off your game.
It doesn’t matter if you do it perfectly. And, in fact, if you aim for that, you’ll sabotage yourself.
3. Don’t skip more than one day.
Another factor to consider is that when you skip a day of performing a habit but return to it the next day, you’re more likely to keep it up. You stay with it.
But if you skip one day, and then another, you’re more likely to miss a third day and then quit.
I’ve found that there have been times I’ve skipped a whole week of exercise for various reasons, like being sick or overwhelmed with work, but because the habit is pretty well established, I get right back to it and keep it going.
I would, however, caution you about the danger of that. If you’re prone to perfectionism, skipping is risky. Better to scale way down in scope, but keep at it.
James Clear describes a guy in his book who started his exercise habit by going to the gym for many days in a row, but only staying for five minutes. His first goal was to establish the habit of showing up. He didn’t even exercise. Once he was used to that, he added working out to his routine.
You might laugh – I did – but it’s ingenious.
The Main Points to Remember
Let’s summarize the key takeaways here, so you have them in mind as you create your new habits.
- The first goal for establishing any new habit is to show up. Showing up can be very small in scope. Five minutes will do. Make it something you won’t resist because it’s so easy.
- The key to success is consistency. What you do repeatedly will stick over time and reduce your resistance. The benefits you feel, the sense of accomplishment, and the rewards will make it easier to keep going.
- Scale back to the smallest action when you are unable to comply with your intended activity fully. Doing something will keep your habit alive. James Clear says, “The secret to winning is knowing how to lose.”
- Keep a running list of the benefits and rewards for the habit you’re working on.
- Stay away from perfectionism and all-or-nothing thinking. Use your setbacks to propel you forward. Start again, no matter what.
If you’d like to know more, listen to Mel Robbins’ podcast interviewing James Clear. It’s called The Science of Making & Breaking Habits: How to Change Your Life in 1 Month. He provides an excellent summary of the main points made in Atomic Habits. It’s great!
Here’s the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dHEG7WxR4c
That’s all for today!
Hope you have a great week and your New Year is off to a good start!
All my best,
Barbara










